Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Posts Tagged ‘Greenbackers’

Tom WoodsOn the January 5, 2014 episode of Exposing Faux Capitalism, I provided a two-hour refutation of Tom Woods’ 2013 presentation paper, “Why the Greenbackers are Wrong.

Here are some highlights:

(2) that fiat money is just fine as long as it is issued by the people’s trusty representatives instead of by the Fed
– It’s not fiat money, since it’s being issued into circulation by the 12 privately-owned Federal Reserve Banks
– Misdirection, since the proposal isn’t to have Representatives and Senators issue money, but to have bankers do it through the U.S. Treasury, under the public trust, akin to the successful Bank of North Dakota.

The Fed pays for this purchase by writing a check on itself, out of thin air, and handing it to the primary dealer.
– Not created out of thin air, but instead, by a bookkeeping entry.

For one thing, pieces of paper with politicians’ faces on them are not saleable goods. They have no use value, and therefore could not have emerged from barter as the most marketable goods in society.
– They do, because of the full faith and credit of the government backing them, which is based ultimately upon the productivity of the people, and the exchange between producers (taxpayers and government).

Second, even if government did try to impose a paper money issued from nothing on the people, it could not be used as a medium of exchange or a tool of economic calculation because no one could know what it was worth. Are three Toms worth one apple or seven fur coats? How could anyone know?
Its value is ultimately determined by the market, and even Lew Rockwell said that not only is the USD a medium of exchange, it’s also money.

This is how unbacked paper money comes into existence. It begins as a convertible substitute for a commodity like gold, and then the government takes the gold away.
– What about the first paper money issued by the Mongols, and what about the United States Notes?

“Free-market money, therefore, is commodity money.”
– Says who? Stephen Zarlenga has documented several other ways that money has arisen, and privately-issued, voluntary, usury-free community currencies have been issued that aren’t commodity-based.

So free-market money does not enter the economy as a loan.
– What about the paper notes issued by banks during the Free Banking Era of the United States? Were they not free-market money, just because they were issued by state-chartered banks?

For consistency’s sake, they should support all forms of debt-free money, including money that takes the form of a good voluntarily produced on the market and without any form of monopoly privilege.
– “They do”, as in me (Jason Erb), Anthony Migchels, George Whitehurst-Berry, Wayne Walton, Tom J. Kennedy and others.

Although the “there isn’t enough money to pay the interest” argument fails, I want to take up a related warning about sound money
– Is gold sound money when it dropped from $1700 to $1200 in 2013?

First of all, no one can expect to print pieces of paper with his face on them and spend them into circulation. Nobody would accept them, needless to say, and as we have seen, it is impossible for money to be introduced ex nihilo in this way. The only kind of money that can emerge on the free market is one that, at least at one time, had been considered a useful commodity. Paper money can come into existence on the free market and without coercion if it serves as a redemption claim for the commodity money, but irredeemable paper money cannot originate without government threats or violence.
– Tom Woods flaunts his ignorance of the success of voluntary, usury-free community currencies, such as Ithaca Hours and mtnHours.

Again, as we saw previously, the pattern is this: a commodity is freely chosen by market participants to serve as money, for convenience paper receipts fully convertible into that money begin to circulate as money substitutes, and finally the government removes the commodity backing from the paper and only the paper circulates.
– In other words, gold doesn’t function directly in a wide-spread way as money.

When Franklin Roosevelt confiscated Americans’ gold in 1933 and gave them paper money in exchange, this money did not enter the system “as debt.” It was a simple act of conversion of specie into paper. (Thanks to J.P. Koning for tracking down that link.)
– If it didn’t enter as debt, why were they still referred to as notes?

the naive confidence in the American political class that the Greenbacker alternative demands is beneath the dignity of a free people.
– By that standard, why trust government with any powers? — In this way, the anarcho-capitalist critics of government-issued money have some credibility on this point, unlike the minarchist critics like Gary North, who still call for government regulation of contracts in his illusory free market gold standard that is just as much a fool’s gold standard as any government-guaranteed gold standard.

Read Full Post »

Tom WoodsOn the Sunday, January 5, 2014 episode of Exposing Faux Capitalism with Jason Erb, from 8 to 10 PM EST, I intend to provide a full critique and refutation of Tom Woods’ 2013 presentation paper, “Why the Greenbackers are Wrong“.

I find it very revealing that he had more time to prepare this paper than to investigate Bitcoin, for instance, which is a privately-issued alternative to the illusory free market gold standard he and most of his compatriots of the Austrian School keep pushing.

You know what they say — when you’re over the target, expect to get some flak.

Read Full Post »

I saw that Tom Woods plans to have former Reagan administration official David Stockman on his January 2, 2014 podcast — the same man who agreed with Bill Maher that “the Second Amendment is bullsh*t”.

He said he wouldn’t have “money cranks” on his show, in reference to “Greenbackers”, yet he has no problem promoting a debate between Austrian economist Bob Murphy and Keynesian economist Paul Krugman, and now having Second Amendment enemy David Stockman on his show.

Here was my comment:

Dr. Woods, you said you wouldn’t have “monetary cranks” on your show, but why are you planning to have a “constitutional crank” and “statist crank” like Stockman who agreed with Bill Maher on his April 12th Real Time show that “the Second Amendment is bullsh*t”, and said, “why would you believe that an 18th century citizen militia, equipped with the equivalent of muskets, has anything to do with liberty?” and “the only way we protect liberty is with the ballot box”?

For more on Tom Woods, see my article, Tom Woods had no time for a Bitcoin conference, yet had time to misrepresent government-issued currencies., and When will Austrian school supporter Tom Woods debate voluntary, interest-free currency reformer Anthony Migchels?

Read Full Post »

Tom WoodsFrom Tom Woods’ April 15, 2013 article, The Greenbackers’ Fake Quote Industry, picked up by LewRockwell.com the following day, I made the following comments, to which Woods responded to:

Bill Still tried to get fake quotations removed from his documentary, The Money Masters, but the copyright holder wouldn’t allow it, for reasons we can only surmise. In 2011, he created this page dedicated to exposing false monetary quotations (http://s6.zetaboards.com/Bill_Still_Reforum/topic/1177385/1/) so it’s good to see that you’ve joined forces with a Greenbacker in the interests of intellectual honesty, Tom.

To which Woods responded:

I happily concede that this speaks well of Bill Still.

Then, I commented:

In 2009, I exposed the fake Jefferson quote you cited above (https://fauxcapitalist.com/2009/10/28/what-thomas-jefferson-said-about-private-banks/) after hearing it so many times and deciding to do my own research and conceding that it must be fake if the word “deflation” wasn’t even used in Jefferson’s time.

To which he responded:

Great. Now if only you could get the 167,000 people who keep propagating the fakes to visit your page, we’d be getting somewhere.

Then, I wrote:

Tom, while fake quotations are often cited by Greenbackers, there are also fake quotations cited by Austrian School adherents, such as this fake Aristotle quotation: “In effect, there is nothing inherently wrong with fiat money, provided we get perfect authority and god-like intelligence for kings.“ We can thank James Dines for propagating that one. I emailed him asking for his source, and he never responded.

To which he responded:

I have never heard of James Dines, and I cannot imagine any serious Austrian falling for such an obvious fake. With the Greenbackers, fake quotations are systematic and everywhere.

Read Full Post »